The World Table

An interactive culinary compendium: recipes, lexicon and study

Punjabi & North Indian · Side

Sarson da Saag

  • Intermediate
  • 40 min
  • roughly 2 of 4 for cost
  • Vegetarian

aromatic · rich · fiery Leads with aromatics blooming from the first bite, richness that coats and comforts, on a slow, honest burn.

Ingredients

  • 800 g sarson (mustard greens), thick stems pulled off
  • 250 g palak (spinach)
  • 150 g bathua (goosefoot greens), or more spinach
  • 4 green chillies
  • 40 g ginger, half chopped and half julienned
  • 50 g makki da atta (maize flour)
  • 500 ml water
  • 10 g salt
  • 60 g ghee
  • 200 g onion, chopped fine
  • 20 g garlic, sliced
  • 150 g tomato, chopped
  • 3 g deghi mirch
  • 40 g white butter, to finish

Equipment

Ice-cream churner

The skills inside

Tadka: blooming spices in fatSteaming: basket, leaf and lidKnife cuts: dice, julienne, biasMashing & puréeing

Allergen screen

Found: gluten · dairy · mustard

Screened for: gluten, dairy, egg, nuts, peanuts, fish, shellfish, molluscs, soy, sesame, celery, mustard, lupin, alcohol. Not screened: sulphites.

Screened by keyword from the ingredient list, not reviewed by a person; check every label for what the list cannot show.

Method

  1. Boil the sarson, palak and bathua uncovered in a heavy pot with the chopped ginger, chillies, salt and water for 45 minutes: they are done when a mustard stem crushes to nothing between thumb and finger and the steam smells sweet rather than sharp. 45 min
  2. Mash the greens in the pot with a wooden churner, pounding and turning for 10 minutes, until the leaves have broken down but you can still feel fibre against the tongue. 10 min
  3. Rain in the makki da atta a little at a time, stirring hard so it cannot clump, and cook 20 minutes more until the saag pulls away from the side of the pot and holds the mark of the spoon. 20 min
  4. In a separate pan brown the onion in the ghee, add the garlic, tomato and deghi mirch, and cook until the oil runs red and separates at the edge, then stir two thirds of the tadka through the saag.
  5. Spoon the rest of the tadka over the top with the ginger julienne and let the white butter melt into it at the table.

How to tell it is going right

This dish has no standard of its own yet. It is judged on the techniques it exercises: checked at the pan, while there is still something to be done about it.

Tadka: blooming spices in fat 22 recipes

  • The fat is at tempering heat before anything goes in, around 180C (350F): one test seed dropped in surfaces and cracks within two or three seconds. A seed that sinks and sits quiet means the fat is cold and everything will steep rather than bloom; fat already hazing and thinning has gone past 200C (390F), and the first thing in will be black before the last thing is in.
  • Ask what went in and in what order, then read it back off the pan: the hardest seeds lead, with ten to twenty seconds before the next addition, and the softest seeds, any leaf and any powdered aromatic go last with only seconds left. Everything tipped in on one drop is a fail even when the pan smells right, because the most delicate thing in it cannot survive the time the hardest one needs.
  • The pan gave a hard scatter of popping that rose, peaked and thinned before it left the heat. A pan that stayed silent never reached popping heat and the seeds are still hard and raw against the teeth; seeds still cracking loudly as it is poured finished blooming in the dish instead of in the fat, where nothing was watching them.
  • Cumin is exactly one shade darker than it went in and no more, a warm even brown that smells nutty and sweet; anything near coffee colour, or smelling of scorch, has already carried bitterness into the fat. Fenugreek is pale gold, checked under the light with nothing copper or brown among it, and this is the mark to judge first: past gold it turns the whole pot bitter, and no salt, sugar or souring will pull it back.
  • The leaf is blistered and gone translucent, still green at the edge and crisp rather than black or limp, and it cracked sharply when it met the fat. It reached the dish still at full heat and answered with a violent hiss, and it reads on the surface afterwards as bright separate fat with whole spices suspended through it, not a dull dark sediment settled on the bottom.

Where it goes wrong The fat was pushed past hazing before anything went in, or every spice was tipped in together, so the hardest and the most delicate cooked on one clock: in the seconds the hardest seeds need to pop, fenugreek goes from gold to brown and the leaf goes black. Nothing can be corrected after that. The tempering pours in dark and smells scorched over the top of the dish, the specks read black rather than brown when the surface is turned to the light, and a flat acrid bitterness arrives at the back of the palate after the swallow and stays there through the next mouthful.

Mashing & puréeing 114 recipes

  • Smooth to the degree the dish asks for, judged on the tongue rather than by eye: no lumps, no fibres, no grit, unless texture is the point.
  • No gluey elasticity: a spoonful drops cleanly off the spoon rather than stretching in a rope behind it.
  • The consistency holds: it mounds on a spoon and stays there, neither slumping flat nor standing so stiff that a spoon has to cut it.
  • Nothing separates on the plate: no water or fat weeping out into a ring within a minute of serving.
  • The colour is even throughout, with no streaks of unincorporated fat, liquid, or seasoning at the edges of the bowl.

Where it goes wrong A starchy ingredient met a high-speed blade, so the cells burst and released their starch: what should be light comes out as an elastic glue that lifts off the spoon in one mass.

At the Table

The Pour
Off-dry Riesling (Mosel Kabinett)
Also Right
Gewürztraminer or off-dry Chenin
From the Taps
Crisp lager or pilsner
Zero-Proof
Agua fresca or iced jasmine tea

Sugar, cold, and low alcohol are the fire code: sweetness tames capsaicin while acid resets the palate; tannin would fan the flames.

Saved on this device and kept across visits: export from My Menu to move them.

Film school

This dish, cooked on camera Search films of Sarson da Saag Technique: Tadka: blooming spices in fatThe skill inside this recipeTechnique: Churning ice creamThe skill inside this recipe The cuisine, deeper Technique films from the Punjabi & North Indian kitchen